BIG BUCK CONTEST IN THE NORTHWOODS
Being the deer gun season started yesterday I guarantee if you were at any Northwoods watering hole prior to this weekend, at some point you heard people talking about deer hunting. If not, these conversations are about deer that have been harvested (Michigan started Nov 15th) and/or deer that Wisconsin hunters hope to get after seeing them on their trail cameras.
I’m pretty sure most of you over the last few weeks have spotted some local businesses have posted BIG BUCK contest posters. Most of these signup sheets allows hunters to choose the location (state) that they are hopeful their buck is harvested in, those being Michigan (Gogebic County) or Wisconsin (Vilas County). Each entry cost $5 and at the end of the contest the winner gets the amount raised.
Over the years, I don’t know if others have, but I’ve noticed a lot of the biggest bucks have been harvested in Michigan. Have you ever wondered why there were less hunters bagging a buck in Wisconsin? I think there are many reasons and right or wrong this is why I believe this is happening.
First of all, there are more Wisconsin hunters heading south to harvest deer because in Southern Wisconsin there is a higher success rate due to a denser population. Then, northern Wisconsin has lost a significant habitat (forest/food) that deer need. Now, add that 6 of the last 9 winters were classified as severe and this can stress deer and increase mortality rates among older deer and fawns.
It could also be due to the number of predators in northern Wisconsin. The number of wolfs the DNR say there are in the state is not true and bears population is estimated over 24K. Now add Bobcats and cougar’s (yes mountain lions) also have an effect on the number of deer in the northern part of the state.
Then there is the difference in wildlife (buck to doe ratio) management between Wisconsin and Michigan, and some are saying Michigan’s plans are much better. Is that true? I dont really know for sure. The last reason I can come up with is the Upper peninsula of Michigan has a lower population of humans per acre and has a quality habitat that supports a stronger deer population.
I’ll keep an eye on the big buck boards to see if my reasons hold merit, but there is a good possibility the biggest buck taken could come from Wisconsin this season. I will let everyone know at the conclusion of this year’s big buck contest.




